On Sunday, October 11, AJJ returned to Canada for a packed show at The Mod Club in Toronto with Greet Death. Before the set, we sat down with Sean Bonnette, co-founder of the American folk-punk band and the writer behind a career of unflinching lyrics. From their 2005 debut, Candy Cigarettes, Capguns, Issue Problems! And Such, to now, each era brings a sound that’s playful and unguarded. We talked about their newest album, Dirty Old Power, and its take on surveillance, from the algorithm to the “circuit” between a band and a crowd, and what it means to admit you got a lyric wrong.
AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Fans watching AJJ perform at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Fans singing along to AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo Greet Death opening for AJJ at The Mod Club. Credit: Weajue Mombo
Weajue: Welcome back to Canada. How’s that been?
Sean Bonnette: Great.
W: Did you have any trouble crossing the border?
SB: It was incredible. We had no trouble. The guy sussed that we were a band really quickly and asked how many shows we were playing. We told him our next three shows, and he said, “Have a good day” and let us through. That’s unheard of. Usually they at least have us get out and ask more questions than that.
W: We’re happy to have you.
SB: Thank you very much. I really love playing in Canada.
W: And you’re playing with Greet Death, which I love. It’s not your first time together.
SB: No, we toured with them about two years ago, for three or four weeks. They’re so great. I love them.
W: I kept getting fascinated by the word “power” on this album. Power has so many connotations, and music itself can be a kind of power. It’s often said that power corrupts. How do you keep music from turning into content, or something flippant?
SB: I was about to disagree with you and say music is an incorruptible power, but it can be corrupted and turned into content, a consumer product. At the end of the day, I do think music defeats all of that. But I really despise that music will make you feel like you’re working for your phone in 2026. Like you’re working for an app.
W: The algorithm.
SB: Yeah. Algorithm, rhythm and blues. What we do to avoid that is not take it too seriously, and not do it when we don’t feel like it. I don’t know if being avoidant of that helps our career, but it helps us play music for longer and keep our eye on what really matters, which is being on stage and the energy transfer between our band and our listeners. And the struggle to find the words, which is the very important thing that music provides.
W: I am very invigorated by the fact that you guys have been in it for some time. What does performing do for you? And do you perform differently knowing there’s an audience watching?
SB: I can only speak for myself, but the best thing about playing live is the feeling of singing. Singing is really good for the soul. Even on the worst day in the world, if I get to play a show and sing for an hour or an hour and a half, I can’t help but come out feeling better. Like I’ve gotten something out that was important to purge, or maybe to invite. I’m not sure. It’s food for the soul.
W: I love that, to purge or to invite. I don’t think they’re necessarily an either/or.
SB: Totally. The audience adds a lot to the collective energy transfer. I envision it as a loop, kind of a circuit. When there’s no audience, the circuit is a lot smaller, because it’s just us and we’re our own audience. When the audience is there, the circuit can be pretty powerful. For the same reason I get a lot out of singing, I think other people do too, particularly if they sing along, though they don’t have to. I think that’s probably why people have loved going to church for so long, and concerts in general. It’s just great to be in a room full of people singing.
W: Is there anything that breaks the circuit?
SB: Nothing for too long. If something really bad happened at a show, that would do it. But we’ve had people break out into fights during the softest song, and once the fight was broken up, it was pretty funny. We got to laugh about it. If the circuit breaks, we tend to repair it pretty quickly.
W: One of the tracks on the record, “Update”, has this imagery of an AI partner, like in the film Her. Do you think there’s ever a point where you’d acquiesce to some of it?
SB: Of an AI partner specifically? Oh man. I watched it and I did like it. I haven’t watched it in a modern context, and I think I’d have a vastly different opinion than I did back then. But I like Spike Jonze. And I found out, as a skateboarder, that the movie was originally called the Untitled Rick Howard Project. Rick Howard is one of the pro skater buddies Spike Jonze has. That funny little bit of trivia just lives in my mind. But as far as companionship with an AI, man, I have no idea. I might just be an old fogey at some point. A friend once told me that one of the next big liberation movements would be for sentient AI. And I don’t want to negate anything’s consciousness, but I feel like they’re not there yet. I definitely think it’s messy, and I think the job of the musician is usually to ask the questions more than tell people how to feel. I think the variety of songs on Dirty Old Power kicks up a bunch of questions, on both sides of that field. But I still think I don’t like it.
W: It’s crazy to think about. But your music has a long history of kicking up questions. Has it ever been thinking ahead of you, asking something you didn’t know you were asking?
SB: Yeah. Stuff that, in retrospect, you can look back on and think, “Oh wow, that was kind of creepy.” Good Luck, Everybody was that for us a lot. It came out in January 2020, right before the lockdown, but even as we were making it, those feelings of isolation and uncertainty were in the air. Listening back, it’s strange how appropriate it seems for that lockdown era.
W: The band’s fanbase is beautiful to witness. We get to watch the evolution of the band, and it becomes a lifeline for a lot of people. Has that ever weighed on you, or is it a lighter thing you appreciate?
SB: I do feel a certain responsibility, but at the same time I think I should be hands off. I find it really beautiful and cool, and I can relate to it as a fan of music myself, as someone who has bands like that.
W: Is there anything on the record you love that nobody pays attention to? Something you’d give flowers to?
SB: I have little favourite things, usually little sounds or overdubs that I just like. But there’s a whole song we love to play that we’re pretty sure the audience couldn’t care less about: “Best Friend,” off Christmas Island. It’s a mid-tempo, kind of Neil Young bop. Real fun to play, real easy to play, and never a super big reaction. More of an “oh yeah, that’s pretty good.”
W: Well, who cares what they think.
SB: Yeah, we’re fine with it. That’s another thing that’s kept us interested in playing our own music for so long- we’re perfectly happy releasing a record we think our fans won’t like at first. I trust that as long as we think it’s good, other people will eventually like it too. When a record comes out polarizing, we usually see that as a good sign. If people have strong opinions on either side, we’ve done something right. History has shown that for us. People hated Can’t Maintain at first, they didn’t like Knife Man, and even People Who Can Eat People Are the Luckiest People in the World, the one people really love, wasn’t particularly well received when it came out. It got mid reviews all the way down.
W: Do you ever feel scared of anything anymore? If you can put out music without worrying what people think, is there anything that scares you?
SB: I’m afraid of losing focus, of not knowing what to do. I’d hate to be rudderless, able to write songs forever but not really care what they’re about. It would bum me out if I could create songs but no longer connected with them. There are artists who can do that and make really good stuff, through collaboration with other people. But I’m afraid of that. So far it hasn’t happened.
W: People call you folk-punk heroes. For the sake of argument, what’s not punk about the band?
SB: A lot of our sounds are very not punk. A lot of our keyboards and cello and instrumentation is more old-fashioned, I would say. Then again, punk is old-fashioned. And we stay in hotels, and everybody gets a bed to sleep in. We used to be really punk, and now we’re not.
W: Sleeping in your van is punk.
SB: For sure.
W: I’ve been reading a lot of anarchist literature, and it feels like even if I have my own beliefs, they don’t mean much unless they’re part of a larger collective. Is there a way you see to propagate that within larger communities?
SB: That’s a super big question. A lot of people, myself included, feel really alienated, politically alienated, from any larger body that can do something to help ourselves and our communities. I think music can help with that, especially if it’s aligned with a political cause. But it’s hard to get momentum going. I saw an idea the other day about working-class organizing: at these meetings and rallies, there should be food. How did someone put it? Serve food, more food, and better food. That shows an amount of care for the people you’re trying to engage politically, and it’s a good incentive to go to an event. I’m also seeing so much more mutual aid, and that term is floating around my community in Tucson, Arizona a whole lot more than it ever has. That’s something great that’s coming out of all this terror.
W: mewithoutYou used to do potlucks before shows. Maybe you could have a potluck for us at some point.
SB: That’d be cool.
W: Are you ever afraid of getting it wrong? How do you sit with that?
SB: I’m afraid of getting it wrong, but I’ve gotten it wrong so many times. I think the best way to handle it is to admit you’re wrong. I’ll use objectionable language in a song from 2005 and realize the word, or the effect I was going for, doesn’t really work. So I can admit I’m wrong and change the word, or stop playing the song.
W: I wondered if you disassociate from the song, but changing it is a valuable option too.
SB: I believe songs are never really finished being written. When they’re recorded, that’s a snapshot of the life the song is leading. A lot of songs continue their lives on stage for as long as we’re playing them, and as a result they keep changing.
W: They’re living documents.
SB: Totally.
W: Thank you so much, Sean.
SB: Thanks for the interview.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Author:
